by Bob Benedetti
After mentoring by pop artist
AND six-time Grammy nominee Gwen Stefani, American Idol's top 10 contestants were prepared
TO take on
THE Pop song genre. Here's how they fared:
LaKisha Jones showed versatility by selecting an up-tempo throwback
TO yesteryear with Donna Summer's Last Dance. Jones topped a personality-filled performance with warm mid-range vocals
AND smooth, shiny attire. Bonus points from panelists Randy Jackson
AND Simon Cowell gave high fashion marks
FOR Jones' knee-high leather boots. Cowell thought
THE Flint, Michigan resident looked "Thirty years younger" this week.
Once again, Chris Sligh showed that his sense
OF humor --
AND musical timing -- were both slightly offbeat.
IN response
TO a fan question, "How do you spend your down time?" Sligh quipped "I like
TO knit
AND crochet." Although
THE rotund, bespectacled lad demonstrated good vocals
IN the latter half
OF Police tune Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic, his fluctuations
IN tempo were detraction. Middle panelist Paula Abdul suggested that Sligh "feel
THE beat."
Gina Glocksen's selection
OF Pretenders hit I'll Stand By You was a perfect fit
AND capped off a sterling delivery. It brilliantly interlaced
THE spiky-haired Chicago native's powerful vocal chops with a sensitive feminine touch that drew a standing ovation
AND glowing reviews from
THE Idol panel.
THE oft-boorish Cowell raved, "It wasn't one
OF your best -- it WAS your best."
Seventeen-year-old Sanjaya Malakar continues
TO find ways
TO leave viewers
AND panelists speechless. This week, an orange colored pony-tail Mohawk standing a foot
IN the air was Malakar's calling card, while dispensing
NO Doubt tune Bath Water. Initial stage inhibitions dissolved
AND the youngster showed a high quality mid-range resonance. Too little, too late? It'd
BE foolish
TO underestimate Malakar's sturdy fan base.
Lead panelist Cowell found Haley Scarnato's try at Cyndi Lauper hit True Colors, "Sweet…
AND forgettable." Her trademark accurate, warm voice
AND compelling presentation seemed deficient on Tuesday evening. With vocal gifts that are comparatively diminutive
TO her peers, Scarnato's effort
IN Colors may
HAVE lagged enough
TO land her a homebound ticket
TO San Antonio.
Blake Lewis also attempted
TO sensitively harmonize a ballad, but his outcome yielded different results.
THE innovative 25-year-old put a softer, blues-ier spin on
THE Cure 's Love Song. A genuine, devoid-of-frills presentation garnered lofty praise from judges Abdul, "…very hip, contemporary,"
AND Cowell, "…the strongest guy
IN the competition."
Phil Stacey
AND Melissa Doolittle took a different approach than Scarnato
AND Lewis by offering sizeable helpings
OF their large, dynamic voices. Stacey showed confidence
AND ambition, selecting
THE Police's 1983 chart-topping Every Breath You Take. Panelist Abdul's assessment was dead on; "…a good [song] choice that… showed off
THE color
AND personality
IN your voice." Meanwhile, Doolittle's contrast
OF personal sheepishness
AND on-stage assertion continued
TO amaze everyone. Her fun-yet-forceful take on Donna Summer's retro hit Heaven Knows drew reviews ranging from "The bomb"
TO "…charisma from
THE word 'go'."
Chris Richardson decided
TO 'play it straight,' taking mentor Stefani's advice
TO "do away with
THE [usual] vocal olympics"
AND just "focus on
THE feeling of
THE song." It paid off, as
NO Doubt ballad Don't Speak drew a positive vibe from Jackson "I liked your 'flavor' on it." Richardson's periodic on-stage uneasiness
AND a tinny musical arrangement (a half-step increase
IN key signature) may
HAVE detracted from
THE viewer experience. This writer is guessing
THE performance may have
THE 22-year-old Virginia resident vying
FOR dismissal from
THE competition.
Jordin Sparks smartly stayed young
AND hip with Stefani pop single Hey Baby. Impressed
AND flattered by
THE choice, Stefani believed that Sparks made it "sound more musical than I thought it was." Although possibly not her best vocal, but it was fun, cool way
TO remind
THE audience
OF her youth (17 years old)
AND versatility. Panelist Jackson reinforced what many
HAVE thought but not expressed, "You could
BE a tremendous recording artist."
FOR now, Sparks is gaining confidence weekly on
THE big stage.
Who stay AND who goes? Tune IN tomorrow, Wednesday March 28th TO Fox at 9pm EST AND watch THE Results Show.